Review likes/dislikes
What I like:
The smaller icons is cool
They open in a new tab

Dislike:
Navigating spaces is NOT intuitive or convenient. I use speed dial chrome extension and it's much easier - the spaces are right there at the top and you just click on it. With minimarks, you have to first click spaces, then click these very tiny little arrows to go to the next space over - and keep clicking until you're in the right space.

I dislike that I can only have text if the minimarks are in a column layout - which then leads to a very very long page. If we're forced to put it into a list format in order to see the name of the item, then why can't we make several columns under each "collection"? Right now, it's only one column in each collection - and I've got lots of collections - so it's this huge list I have to scroll down to find my item. So the list and organization of it is not very pleasant or user friendly.

We can't customize images - in the event that minimarks can't fetch the image, which happens relatively often, you should be able to add a url to your own custom image. Right now, when it can't fetch the image, I'm left with a little square and the icon that shows it can't fetch. Additionally, many of my links share the same icon - for example, when I've got links to different folders in google drive. So they all look identical - and without text, you can't distinguish. So you're stuck in list format - a never ending list.

Don't love that I have to go into "edit mode" to change the name of the item. Why can't we just right click on it? Instead, I have to click another button to go into edit mode > then click the icon > then select edit from the menu > then type the new name > then click to save and exit edit mode. It just seems like an unnecessary process that could be simplified.

The apps a great idea, but I think it's poor execution. But if you're someone who really doesn't have a ton of icons/links you need to save, then maybe it's great for those cases.

I also don't love that the minimarks dashboard itself is another page you have to go to first in order to then see your bookmarks. I hate to harp on the speed dial thing but it's automatically open as your browser screen when you open the browser. That's a lot more convenient.

Why 4 stars? Two reasons: first, I gave it five stars and AppSumo rejected my review because of that. So I had to leave one less.

Second, because minimarks isn't doing anything wrong - so who am I to give them a bad review just because it's not what I specifically expected? This info is based on my specific use case - but as you can see they've got tons of 5-star reviews so I would still give it a shot.